
Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn
Best for neighborhood exploration, nightlife, and a social rooftop pool scene in Williamsburg.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn is a lively, neighborhood-focused hotel in Williamsburg with a seasonal rooftop pool and three on-site food & drink venues; read this if you want a social Brooklyn base near transit and nightlife. The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel is an Upper East Side luxury hotel close to Central Park and the Met; read this if you prioritize a quieter, classic Manhattan luxury stay with a full-service spa and fine dining.
Updated · about 6.0 km apart

Best for neighborhood exploration, nightlife, and a social rooftop pool scene in Williamsburg.

Best for a classic Manhattan luxury stay steps from Central Park and museum walking routes, with a dedicated spa and fine-dining option.
When Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn wins: choose Hotel Indigo for a younger, social Brooklyn vibe, easy subway access to Manhattan, a seasonal rooftop outdoor pool with skyline views, and multiple in-house dining venues that fit a lively neighborhood itinerary.
When The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel wins: pick The Surrey when you want a quieter, high-service Upper East Side base within a five-minute walk of Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art, Frette sheets and down comforters, and on-site spa services plus valet/limo options.
Bottom line: Hotel Indigo is the pick for Brooklyn-focused, social stays and event-ready capacity; The Surrey is the pick for classic Manhattan luxury, proximity to museums and parkland, and a more traditional full-service hotel experience.
| Category | Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn | The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Lively Brooklyn neighborhood hotel with social restaurants, rooftop pool and event space | Upper East Side luxury hotel, quieter and service-focused |
| Location | 500 Metropolitan Ave, Williamsburg, Brooklyn — steps from Metropolitan Ave subway and Bedford Ave | 20 East 76th Street, Upper East Side — ~0.2 km from Central Park and near the Met |
| Size (rooms) | 187 rooms (opened 2019) | 100 guestrooms |
| Check-in min age | 21 (primary guest) | |
| Pools / beach | 1 seasonal outdoor rooftop pool (sundeck, cabanas; age-separated hours) | No pool listed in supplier materials |
| Restaurants & bars | Three venues: Continent Brooklyn (Caribbean-Asian fusion), Aliya Cocktail Den (lounge), Kēap Sipping Cafe & Bar (lobby cafe) | Casa Tua (Italian restaurant & bar) plus 24-hour room service and breakfast for a surcharge |
| Spa & wellness | No dedicated spa (rooms described as having spa-inspired bathrooms); 24-hour fitness center and fitness partnership | Full-service spa with massage and facial treatments, plus 24-hour fitness facilities |
| Known for | Rooftop pool, large event/wedding capacity (nearly 20,000 sq ft of event space) | Central Park and museum proximity, luxury bedding (Frette) and concierge/valet service |
| Parking & transport | Controlled-access covered self-parking (fee, limited, reserve in advance); steps from subway | Valet parking (surcharge) and limo/town car service available; easy Manhattan crosstown access |
| Pet policy | Pet-friendly (dogs up to 50 lb) with a pet fee | Pet fee listed (supplier listing: USD 275 per pet, per stay); service animals exempt |
Hotel Indigo sits in the heart of Williamsburg with immediate subway access and a short walk to Bedford Avenue and waterfront parks.
Choose Hotel Indigo for a Brooklyn neighborhood stay where nightlife, local restaurants and quick subway links matter.
The Surrey is on East 76th Street, a five-minute walk from Central Park and a short stroll to the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
Choose The Surrey if you want a classic Upper East Side base for park and museum visits.
Hotel Indigo offers a range of rooms and suites with some private balconies and loft options that emphasize local design.
Hotel Indigo’s rooms suit travelers wanting contemporary Brooklyn design and some outdoor room options.
The Surrey’s 100 guestrooms are appointed for luxury comfort with Frette Italian sheets and down comforters.
The Surrey is for travelers who prefer traditional luxury room amenities and refined bedding/linens.
Hotel Indigo’s food and drink outlets lean into Caribbean-Asian flavors and neighborhood café culture.
Pick Hotel Indigo for casual, social dining and a lively restaurant scene that connects to the rooftop deck.
The Surrey’s dining centers on Italian cuisine and in-room dining with higher-service touches.
The Surrey is better suited to travelers after table-service Italian dining and full-service room amenities.
Hotel Indigo’s signature amenity is its seasonal rooftop outdoor pool with a sundeck and poolside bar.
The rooftop pool is a central social feature at Hotel Indigo — ideal in warm months but seasonal.
The Surrey does not list an on-site pool in the supplier materials; its draw is park/proximity rather than a pool deck.
The Surrey focuses on classic city luxury and park access rather than a hotel pool feature.
Hotel Indigo pairs a 24-hour fitness center with a rooftop that turns into an evening social spot.
If fitness and an evening rooftop social scene are priorities, Hotel Indigo fits that brief.
The Surrey emphasizes spa services and a quieter evening atmosphere consistent with the Upper East Side.
The Surrey is preferable for travelers prioritizing spa treatments and low-key, refined evenings.

Hotel Indigo — seasonal rooftop pool, poolside bar, cabanas and skyline views.

The Surrey — about a five-minute walk to Central Park and very close to the Metropolitan Museum of Art.

Hotel Indigo — nearly 20,000 sq ft of flexible event space including a 6,630 sq ft ballroom.

The Surrey — full-service spa, luxury linens (Frette) and classic high-service amenities.
Hotel Indigo is family-friendly with all-ages pool hours in the morning; The Surrey accommodates families but presents a quieter, more adult-focused environment.
No — both properties list breakfast as available for a surcharge rather than included in standard room rates.
The Surrey has a full-service spa with massage and facial services. Hotel Indigo’s rooms are described as having spa-inspired bathrooms but the property does not list a dedicated spa facility.
Hotel Indigo has immediate subway access (Metropolitan Avenue station at the doorstep) for direct Manhattan lines; The Surrey is a short taxi or subway ride from many Manhattan destinations but is itself on the Upper East Side.
Explore how Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·