
Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn
Best for Brooklyn neighborhood life, rooftop pool hours for families and easy subway access to Manhattan.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn is a neighborhood-focused, design-forward hotel in Williamsburg with a seasonal rooftop pool and multiple on-site dining venues — good for travelers who want Brooklyn nightlife, waterfront parks and easy subway access. Mandarin Oriental, New York is a high-rise luxury hotel at Columbus Circle with full-service spa, indoor pool and Central Park access — read this if you want Manhattan convenience, skyline views and upscale spa services.
Updated

Best for Brooklyn neighborhood life, rooftop pool hours for families and easy subway access to Manhattan.

Best for luxury spa treatments, indoor pool access year-round and direct proximity to Central Park and Manhattan attractions.
When Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn wins: choose Hotel Indigo if you want to be in Williamsburg — near Bedford Avenue, Domino Park and the local restaurants/music venues — and if a seasonal rooftop pool, on-site Caribbean-Asian dining and flexible event space matter more than a downtown Manhattan address.
When Mandarin Oriental, New York wins: pick Mandarin Oriental for a true Manhattan luxury stay with a full-service spa, an indoor pool and immediate access to Central Park, Lincoln Center and Columbus Circle-area attractions.
Bottom line: pick Hotel Indigo for a Brooklyn neighborhood, rooftop-pool and event-focused stay; pick Mandarin Oriental for Manhattan location, year-round spa and indoor-pool amenities.
| Category | Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn | Mandarin Oriental, New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Neighborhood, design-forward Brooklyn hotel with lively dining and rooftop social spaces. | High-rise, luxury Manhattan hotel with formal service and full spa facilities. |
| Location | 500 Metropolitan Ave, Williamsburg, Brooklyn — steps from Metropolitan Ave subway and Bedford Ave. | 80 Columbus Circle at 60th Street — steps from Columbus Circle and Central Park. |
| Size (rooms) | 187 rooms | 244 guestrooms |
| Ages / family policy | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 21; pool hours split for families versus 21+. | Family-friendly (up to 2 children 12 and younger stay free in existing bedding); not adults-only. |
| Pools | One seasonal rooftop outdoor pool (closed for winter season; age-specific hours). | One indoor pool (available year-round). |
| Restaurants & bars | Three on-site venues incl. Continent Brooklyn (Caribbean-Asian), Aliya Cocktail Den, Kēap cafe/bar. | One restaurant plus 2 bars/lounges; 24-hour room service and MO Lounge mentioned. |
| Spa & wellness | No verified dedicated spa; rooms have 'spa-inspired' bathrooms; 24-hour fitness center. | Full-service spa with treatments, sauna and fitness facilities. |
| Event space | Nearly 20,000 sq ft of meeting/event space including a 6,630 sq ft ballroom and outdoor courtyard. | Meeting rooms and a ballroom listed (number of meeting rooms: 1 in supplier listing). |
| Accessibility & services | Concierge, 24-hour front desk, laundry/dry cleaning, covered self-parking (fee), pet-friendly (dogs up to 50 lb). | Concierge, 24-hour front desk, valet parking (surcharge), limo/town car service, multilingual staff. |
| Free Wi‑Fi | Yes — in rooms and public areas. | |
Hotel Indigo sits in Williamsburg, Brooklyn near the Metropolitan Avenue subway stop and Bedford Avenue.
Choose Hotel Indigo for a local Williamsburg experience and easy subway links to Manhattan.
Mandarin Oriental, New York is at Columbus Circle with immediate access to Central Park and Manhattan cultural sites.
Choose Mandarin Oriental for a central Manhattan location and direct access to major city sights.
Hotel Indigo offers a range of rooms and suites, with some rooms featuring private balconies and spa-inspired bathrooms.
Rooms at Hotel Indigo emphasize local design touches, balcony options and practical amenities for Brooklyn stays.
Mandarin Oriental has 244 guestrooms with premium bedding and in-room technology.
Mandarin Oriental focuses on luxury finishes, larger TVs and plush bedding for a high-end Manhattan stay.
Hotel Indigo features three on-site dining venues with a Caribbean-Asian focus and casual cafe options.
Hotel Indigo offers lively, locally inspired dining choices geared to Brooklyn’s food scene.
Mandarin Oriental provides formal hotel dining with 1 restaurant, multiple bars and 24-hour room service.
Mandarin Oriental focuses on classic luxury hotel dining and in-room service rather than multiple neighborhood outlets.
Hotel Indigo’s headline amenity is a seasonal rooftop outdoor pool with skyline views and a poolside bar.
Pick Hotel Indigo for a summer rooftop-pool vibe and skyline views; it’s seasonal and subject to age-specific hours.
Mandarin Oriental lists an indoor pool among its recreational amenities for year-round use.
Mandarin Oriental is the better choice if you want a year-round pool plus a full-service spa.
Hotel Indigo pairs a 24-hour fitness center with neighborhood nightlife close by.
Hotel Indigo matches around-the-clock fitness access with easy walking access to Brooklyn’s nightlife.
Mandarin Oriental centers wellness around a full-service spa, fitness facilities and premium in-hotel services.
Mandarin Oriental is geared to guests seeking professional spa services and formal hotel nightlife settings.

Hotel Indigo is in Williamsburg with the subway at its doorstep and easy access to local bars, parks and markets.

Mandarin Oriental has a full-service spa and an indoor pool for use regardless of season.

Hotel Indigo offers nearly 20,000 sq ft of flexible event space including a 6,630 sq ft ballroom and outdoor courtyard options.

Mandarin Oriental puts you steps from Central Park, Columbus Circle and Midtown attractions.
Hotel Indigo and Mandarin Oriental both welcome families; Hotel Indigo has all-ages morning pool hours and local attractions ideal for kids, while Mandarin Oriental offers complimentary policies for young children in existing bedding and a year-round indoor pool.
Mandarin Oriental, New York has a full-service spa; Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn does not have a verified on-site spa (rooms are described as having 'spa-inspired' bathrooms).
Mandarin Oriental has an indoor pool available year-round. Hotel Indigo’s rooftop pool is seasonal and closed in the winter, with reopening expected after May 2027.
Mandarin Oriental is at Columbus Circle, adjacent to Central Park. Hotel Indigo is in Williamsburg, Brooklyn and is not adjacent to Central Park.
Explore how Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·