
Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn
Best for weekend stays focused on Williamsburg nightlife, local dining, and rooftop pool time.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn is a modern, neighborhood-focused hotel in Williamsburg with a seasonal rooftop pool and three on-site dining venues—good for travelers who want Brooklyn nightlife and waterfront access. The Peninsula New York is a 5-star Fifth Avenue luxury hotel with a full-service spa and indoor pool—best for travelers seeking polished Midtown service and proximity to MoMA and Rockefeller Center.
Updated · about 7 km apart

Best for weekend stays focused on Williamsburg nightlife, local dining, and rooftop pool time.

Best for a traditional Midtown luxury experience with spa treatments, indoor pool access, and close walking distance to major museums and shopping.
When Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn wins: choose Hotel Indigo if you want to stay in Williamsburg, use a rooftop seasonal pool, be steps from subway links to Manhattan, or plan weddings and large events—the hotel offers extensive event space.
When The Peninsula New York wins: choose The Peninsula for a classic Midtown luxury stay with a full-service spa, an indoor pool, 24-hour fitness facilities, and immediate walking access to 5th Avenue, MoMA, and Rockefeller Center.
Bottom line: pick Hotel Indigo for a neighborhood Brooklyn experience with lively dining and a rooftop pool; pick The Peninsula for refined Midtown luxury, spa services, and easy access to Manhattan attractions.
| Category | Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn | The Peninsula New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary Brooklyn neighborhood hotel with lively dining and rooftop social spaces | Traditional Fifth Avenue luxury hotel with formal services and classic public rooms |
| Location | 500 Metropolitan Ave, Williamsburg, Brooklyn—steps from Metropolitan Ave subway | 700 Fifth Avenue at 55th Street—steps from 5th Avenue and MoMA |
| Size (rooms) | 187 rooms (opened 2019) | 219 guestrooms |
| Audience / age policy | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 21 (pool has age-specific hours) | All ages welcome; not adults-only (minimum check-in age 21 at property) |
| Pools | 1 seasonal rooftop outdoor pool (sundeck, cabanas); age-segregated hours; closed in winter season | 1 indoor pool (indoor pool available; pool hours and rules published by hotel) |
| Restaurants & bars | Three on-site venues: Continent Brooklyn (Caribbean-Asian fusion), Aliya Cocktail Den, Kēap Sipping Cafe & Bar | Clement Restaurant (American) plus 3 bars/lounges and 24-hour room service |
| Wellness & fitness | 24-hour fitness center; no verified dedicated on-site spa — rooms have 'spa-inspired' bathrooms | Full-service spa (massages, body treatments, facials), 24-hour health club and sauna |
| Known for | Rooftop pool, Williamsburg location and dining led by Continent Brooklyn | Beaux-Arts Fifth Avenue presence, luxury service, proximity to MoMA and Rockefeller Center |
| Events & meetings | Nearly 20,000 sq ft of flexible event space including a 6,630 sq ft ballroom and outdoor courtyard | Multiple meeting rooms (5) and banquet/meeting facilities for business and events |
| Pets & parking | Pet-friendly (dogs up to 50 lb; fee applies), covered self-parking for a fee (onsite limited) | Pets allowed policy: Not published; secured valet parking available (surcharge) |
Hotel Indigo is embedded in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, near subway access and local attractions.
Choose Hotel Indigo for a Brooklyn neighborhood stay and easy subway access to Manhattan.
The Peninsula sits on Fifth Avenue in Midtown, within immediate walking distance of major Manhattan sights.
Choose The Peninsula for a stay focused on Midtown museums, shopping, and sightseeing on foot.
Hotel Indigo offers a mix of standard rooms, premium rooms with balconies, lofts and suites designed for Brooklyn stays.
Rooms emphasize local design and outdoor views in select categories.
The Peninsula’s 219 guestrooms are positioned as classic luxury rooms with premium bedding and in-room amenities.
Rooms focus on traditional luxury comforts and in-room service.
Hotel Indigo’s food and drink leans into local and fusion influences with three distinct outlets.
Good fit for travelers who value neighborhood restaurants and lively cocktail spaces.
The Peninsula provides classic hotel dining with an American restaurant and multiple lounges.
Better if you prefer formal hotel dining, late room service, and lounge variety in Midtown.
Hotel Indigo’s headline amenity is a seasonal rooftop outdoor pool with skyline views.
Choose Hotel Indigo if a summer rooftop pool and skyline views matter to you.
The Peninsula offers indoor pool access alongside a full-service spa and wellness facilities.
Choose The Peninsula year-round for indoor pool and dedicated spa treatments.
Hotel Indigo pairs a 24-hour fitness center with access to Williamsburg nightlife.
Good choice if you want to combine workouts with local after-dark scenes.
The Peninsula centers wellness around a spa and indoor fitness facilities with quieter evening options nearby.
Better for travelers who prioritize spa treatments and formal evening entertainment.

Hotel Indigo’s seasonal rooftop pool, cabanas and skyline views make it the clear pick for warm‑season rooftop time.

The Peninsula’s address on Fifth Avenue puts MoMA, Rockefeller Center and high-end shopping within easy walking distance.

The Peninsula provides a full-service spa, indoor pool, sauna, and 24-hour health club for year-round wellness.

Hotel Indigo offers nearly 20,000 sq ft of event space, a 6,630 sq ft ballroom and an outdoor courtyard for weddings and conferences.
Hotel Indigo accommodates families with all-ages morning pool hours and nearby family attractions; The Peninsula allows children but is more focused on luxury services and spa amenities.
The Peninsula has an indoor pool available year-round; Hotel Indigo’s rooftop pool is seasonal and closes for the winter season.
Both hotels list LaGuardia (LGA) as the nearest preferred airport; travel times vary by traffic—Peninsula is in Midtown Manhattan, Hotel Indigo is in Brooklyn with good subway connections.
No dedicated on-site spa has been verified for Hotel Indigo; room descriptions mention 'spa-inspired' bathrooms but aggregators list 'No spa' for the property.
Explore how Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·