
Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn
Best for neighborhood energy, large events, and a rooftop pool with skyline views in Brooklyn.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn is a modern, event-ready boutique in Williamsburg with a seasonal rooftop pool and large meeting spaces; read this if you want a lively Brooklyn neighborhood base with easy subway links. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel is a long-running Upper East Side luxury property known for old‑New‑York service and Bemelman's Bar; read this if you want classic Manhattan formality and proximity to Central Park and the city’s museums.
Updated · about 6.5 km apart

Best for neighborhood energy, large events, and a rooftop pool with skyline views in Brooklyn.

Best for traditional Manhattan luxury, a full‑service spa, and walking distance to Central Park and major museums.
When Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn wins: choose Hotel Indigo if you want a younger, more local Brooklyn atmosphere, on‑site nightlife and restaurants that reflect Williamsburg’s scene, and large flexible event and wedding spaces.
When The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel wins: pick The Carlyle for formal, old‑New‑York luxury, classic service, well‑known food and drink outlets (like Bemelman's Bar), and extremely convenient access to Central Park and the city’s top museums.
Bottom line: pick Hotel Indigo for a social Brooklyn stay with a rooftop pool and big event capacity; pick The Carlyle for an Upper East Side luxury experience and museum/park proximity.
| Category | Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn | The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary Brooklyn boutique, lively neighborhood energy | Classic Upper East Side, formal luxury and history |
| Location | 500 Metropolitan Ave, Williamsburg — steps from subway and local nightlife | 35 E 76th St, Upper East Side — within a 10‑minute walk of Central Park and the Met |
| Size | 187 (reported) rooms; large meeting/event footprint (~20,000 sq ft) | 188 guestrooms |
| Pool | One seasonal rooftop outdoor pool with sundeck, cabanas, age‑restricted hours | No on‑site pool published |
| Restaurants & bars | Three venues on site (Continent Brooklyn, Aliya Cocktail Den, Kēap Sipping Cafe & Bar) | Two restaurants and Bemelman's Bar; 24‑hour room service |
| Spa & wellness | 24‑hour fitness center; rooms described as having 'spa‑inspired bathrooms' but no dedicated spa listed | Full‑service spa and health club listed |
| Known for | Rooftop pool, large wedding and conference spaces, Brooklyn neighborhood access | Art‑Deco luxury, celebrity history, proximity to Central Park and museums |
| Family policy | Not adults‑only; minimum check‑in age 21 with designated all‑ages pool hours in the morning | |
| Wi‑Fi & connectivity | Free Wi‑Fi in rooms and public areas; wired access also listed | |
| Parking & arrival | Limited covered self‑parking nearby (fee, advance reservation recommended) | Valet parking (surcharge) |
Hotel Indigo sits on Metropolitan Avenue in Williamsburg with immediate subway access and a short walk to waterfront parks and Bedford Avenue.
Best if you want to be in the heart of Williamsburg with fast subway links to Manhattan.
The Carlyle is on East 76th Street on the Upper East Side, a short walk from Central Park and the city’s major museums.
Best if you want classic Manhattan addresses and walking access to the park and museums.
Hotel Indigo offers contemporary rooms and suites, some with private balconies or terraces, and design notes like spa‑inspired bathrooms.
Choose Hotel Indigo for contemporary, often balcony‑equipped rooms and a more casual room style.
The Carlyle lists a long roster of room types from Superior King and Deluxe Rooms to many named suites.
Choose The Carlyle if you want classic, full‑service luxury rooms and a wide selection of suites.
Hotel Indigo’s on‑site dining emphasizes Caribbean‑Asian fusion and a casual lobby cafe plus a cocktail den.
Better for guests who want restaurant concepts reflecting Brooklyn’s culinary scene and late-night options.
The Carlyle provides formal dining options, a renowned bar, and round‑the‑clock room service.
Better for travelers who prefer formal dining, historic bars, and concierge‑led restaurant service.
Hotel Indigo’s notable public amenity is a seasonal rooftop outdoor pool with views and a poolside bar.
Pick Hotel Indigo if a rooftop pool and poolside social hours matter to your stay.
The Carlyle does not list an on‑site swimming pool in supplier materials.
Choose The Carlyle for spa and club facilities rather than swimming on site.
Hotel Indigo provides a 24‑hour fitness center and on‑site bars that stay open late on weekends.
Go here for round‑the‑clock workouts and a local nightlife feel right inside the hotel.
The Carlyle lists a full‑service spa, health club and a single bar/lounge with historic cachet.
Pick The Carlyle if a traditional spa and quiet, refined evening options fit your trip.

Hotel Indigo — seasonal rooftop pool with cabanas, poolside bar, and skyline vistas.

The Carlyle — formal service, historic reputation, and proximity to Central Park and museums.

Hotel Indigo — nearly 20,000 sq ft of flexible event space including a 6,630 sq ft ballroom and outdoor courtyard.

The Carlyle — full‑service spa and health club offerings packaged with a 5‑star experience.
The Carlyle — it’s within a short walk of Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn — it has a seasonal rooftop pool; The Carlyle does not list a pool.
Hotel Indigo — the property advertises nearly 20,000 sq ft of event space including a large ballroom and outdoor venues.
Both accept families, though Hotel Indigo has a minimum check‑in age of 21 for the primary guest and age‑split pool hours; The Carlyle is not listed as adults‑only.
Explore how Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·