
Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn
Best for neighborhood-focused travelers who want rooftop pool hours, casual dining, and easy subway access to Manhattan.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn is a contemporary, full-service hotel in Williamsburg aimed at travelers who want a Brooklyn neighborhood stay with a seasonal rooftop pool and lively dining. The St. Regis New York is a historic, 5-star Midtown Manhattan property known for formal, high-end service — read this if you’re choosing between buzzy Brooklyn energy and classic New York luxury.
Updated · about 6.5 km apart

Best for neighborhood-focused travelers who want rooftop pool hours, casual dining, and easy subway access to Manhattan.

Best for travelers who want a classic luxury Midtown address close to 5th Avenue, Rockefeller Center, and formal hotel service.
When Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn wins: choose Hotel Indigo if you want a younger, neighborhood-focused Brooklyn base with a seasonal rooftop pool, multiple casual dining options on site, and easy access to Williamsburg nightlife and the subway.
When The St. Regis New York wins: pick The St. Regis for a traditional ultra-luxury Midtown experience, a central address steps from 5th Avenue and Rockefeller Center, formal service including butler-served room types, and large meeting/banquet capabilities.
Bottom line: Hotel Indigo is the practical, social Brooklyn option with a rooftop pool and event flexibility; The St. Regis is for travelers who prioritize a classic, high-end Midtown New York experience and formal service.
| Category | Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn | The St. Regis New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary, neighborhood-focused, casual-luxe | Historic, formal ultra-luxury |
| Location | Williamsburg, Brooklyn — steps from Metropolitan Ave subway | Midtown Manhattan — Two East 55th St, steps from 5th Avenue |
| Size (guest rooms) | 187 rooms | 238 rooms |
| Check-in / Check-out | Check-in 3:00 PM · Check-out 11:00 AM | Check-in 4:00 PM · Check-out 12:00 PM |
| Pools | Seasonal outdoor rooftop pool with age-specific hours and poolside bar | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Three on-site venues (Continent Brooklyn, Aliya Cocktail Den, Kēap Sipping Cafe & Bar) | 2 restaurants and 1 bar/lounge; room service available (limited hours) |
| Spa / wellness | No dedicated spa (spa-inspired bathrooms in rooms) | Not published |
| Fitness | 24-hour fitness center (cardio, weights) | |
| Event space | Nearly 20,000 sq ft of flexible meeting/event space including a 6,630 sq ft ballroom and outdoor courtyard | Conference space ~3,944 sq ft with 13 meeting rooms (large historic meeting facilities) |
| Accessibility & family policy | Not adults-only; minimum check-in age 21; family-friendly pool hours | Not adults-only; welcomes all ages (minimum check-in age 21 at property) |
Hotel Indigo sits in Williamsburg with direct access to local bars, restaurants, and the Metropolitan Avenue subway.
Choose Hotel Indigo if you want a Brooklyn neighborhood base with easy subway links into Manhattan.
The St. Regis is located on East 55th Street, just off 5th Avenue in Midtown Manhattan.
Choose The St. Regis to be in the center of Midtown with many major attractions within walking distance.
Hotel Indigo’s rooms lean modern with some options offering balconies or terraces and spa-inspired bathrooms.
Hotel Indigo is for travelers who want modern rooms with some outdoor options and practical in-room services.
The St. Regis offers classic luxury rooms and multiple butler-served room types and suites.
The St. Regis is for travelers who want traditional, service-forward luxury rooms and suites with butler service options.
Hotel Indigo emphasizes three distinct on-site venues blending Caribbean-Asian flavors, cocktails, and a lobby café.
Hotel Indigo suits guests who prefer lively, neighborhood-oriented dining and craft cocktails.
The St. Regis offers two restaurants, a bar/lounge, and limited-hours room service.
The St. Regis fits travelers who expect classic hotel dining and concierge-arranged restaurant options near Midtown attractions.
Hotel Indigo’s seasonal rooftop pool is a prominent guest amenity in summer months.
Pick Hotel Indigo if a summer rooftop pool and skyline views are important to your stay.
The St. Regis listing does not publish an on-site pool.
Pool access at The St. Regis is not published; inquire with the hotel if a pool is a deciding factor.
Hotel Indigo offers 24-hour fitness plus a lively local nightlife scene in Williamsburg.
Hotel Indigo pairs round-the-clock gym access with nearby Brooklyn nightlife and on-site evening venues.
The St. Regis provides 24-hour fitness facilities along with high-end hotel evening service.
Choose The St. Regis for formal service, convenient access to Midtown theater and nightlife, and 24-hour gym facilities.

Hotel Indigo — seasonal rooftop pool with skyline views and poolside bar; family and adults-only hours.

The St. Regis — historic 5-star address steps from 5th Avenue and Rockefeller Center with butler-served room types.

Hotel Indigo — nearly 20,000 sq ft of flexible event space including a 6,630 sq ft ballroom and outdoor courtyard.

The St. Regis — extensive suite inventory and many rooms listing 'Butler Service Included.'
The St. Regis is the clear choice — it’s on East 55th Street a short walk from 5th Avenue, Rockefeller Center and MoMA.
Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn has a seasonal rooftop pool with age-specific hours; The St. Regis does not publish a pool on its supplier listing.
Neither property is strictly adults-only. Both require an adult to check in (minimum age 21), but Hotel Indigo provides all-ages pool hours in the mornings.
Hotel Indigo offers extensive event space (nearly 20,000 sq ft) including a large ballroom and outdoor courtyard, making it well suited for larger events.
Explore how Hotel Indigo Williamsburg - Brooklyn stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·